Gear Selection Problem

Started by NClark, 25 Oct, 2026, 13:53

Previous topic - Next topic

NClark

While I'm generally very pleased with my recently acquired 1961 B40, I've found an intermittent problem with gear selection. Starting off in first and going up through the gears is fine, but sometimes when coming down through the ratios, first and second will not engage.

When this happens the gear lever is almost locked solid, with very little movement. Changing up and down between third and fourth is unaffected, perfectly normal, but second and first are unavailable. This problem seems worse when engine and 'box are cold.

Stopping (without turning off the engine) often allows the lower gears to be selected after a few prods of the gear lever. Once warmed up, the lower gears will select on the move, though the slower the speed, the easier the third down to second change becomes. Once down into second, changing down to first isn't a problem.

Please can I ask if anyone has experienced similar symptoms, or what the cause could be? I'm wondering if there's an issue with the detent plungers engagement with the cam plate?? But I'm hoping not to need to dive that deep into the gearbox!

Nigel

Kev D

#1
Quote from: NClark on 25 Oct, 2026, 13:53 While I'm generally very pleased with my recently acquired 1961 B40, I've found an intermittent problem with gear selection. Starting off in first and going up through the gears is fine, but sometimes when coming down through the ratios, first and second will not engage.

When this happens the gear lever is almost locked solid, with very little movement. Changing up and down between third and fourth is unaffected, perfectly normal, but second and first are unavailable. This problem seems worse when engine and 'box are cold.

Stopping (without turning off the engine) often allows the lower gears to be selected after a few prods of the gear lever. Once warmed up, the lower gears will select on the move, though the slower the speed, the easier the third down to second change becomes. Once down into second, changing down to first isn't a problem.

Please can I ask if anyone has experienced similar symptoms, or what the cause could be? I'm wondering if there's an issue with the detent plungers engagement with the cam plate?? But I'm hoping not to need to dive that deep into the gearbox!

Nigel
You might be doing this already, but when l dip the clutch lever l aways give  a little blip on the throttle as l change down. The gears seem to mesh with less resistance .
   As l said ,you might be already doing this  though.

NClark

Thank you Kev. I do usually blip the throttle changing down, but on my B40 it doesn't make any difference selecting first or second. I've never had a bike with this particular gear change problem before.

Nigel

V500

I had similar issues with an Empire Star I had some years ago. Turned out the PO had used too viscous oil in the gearbox, and until it was really warmed up the pinions were reluctant to slide into engagement as far as they were designed to.
Cheap enough to try, anyway.

NClark

Quote from: V500 on 25 Oct, 2026, 17:16 I had similar issues with an Empire Star I had some years ago. Turned out the PO had used too viscous oil in the gearbox, and until it was really warmed up the pinions were reluctant to slide into engagement as far as they were designed to.
Cheap enough to try, anyway.

Thank you,that makes sense, and would explain why the problem isn't so bad when warmed up. I'll try an oil change. Different oil types are quoted by the Haynes manual and other sources. Can anyone here say what oil spec would be best for a 1961 B40? I normally use EP90 GL-4 in my Triumphs from this era.

Nigel

rhyatt

The correct gbox oil is sae40 straight monograde and the correct primary oil is sae 20.
Do check the clutch pushrod freely after screwing in the clutch cable adjusting screw.
Screw pushrod adjuster in until it stops and then back out 1/2 turn
Start from there

NClark

Quote from: rhyatt on 25 Oct, 2026, 19:14 The correct gbox oil is sae40 straight monograde and the correct primary oil is sae 20.
Do check the clutch pushrod freely after screwing in the clutch cable adjusting screw.
Screw pushrod adjuster in until it stops and then back out 1/2 turn
Start from there

Thank you, much appreciated.

Nigel

Andy Kay

My best friend owns 3 WD B40's, one he acquired was a rolling chassis with the engine out.
He had a similar problem. He checked everything before putting the engine in and on the bench, from neutral he could select 1st and go up the box to 4th, but when coming back down the box it would not go below 2nd gear.
He had to remove the gearbox cover and clusters and refit everything back in the neutral position, but the same thing occurred when trying the gears.
After much head scratching and research, it was discovered that the gear quadrant was fouling the casing and everything was cured with a file.
It also appears that the quadrants in different year models were slightly different and not interchangeable. Not to mention the problems with poor quality pattern parts.
I hope changing the oil cures your problem and you don't have to resort to stripping the gearbox.

NClark

Thank you Andy. Your friend's gearbox troubles sound like a real test of patience, but good to know. I sincerely hope my bike isn't so challenging!

Nigel

rhyatt

looking at the 1st post about the difficulty when cold/hot is a classic indication of wrong viscosity of oil in the gbox, try the correct sae 40 in box and sae 20 in primary and of course the clutch pushrod adjustment as mentioned earlier

limeyrob

It looks recently rebuilt. Do you know if the PO did any work on the box?  It could be some new parts being a bit stiff.

NClark

Quote from: limeyrob on 26 Oct, 2026, 09:54 It looks recently rebuilt. Do you know if the PO did any work on the box?  It could be some new parts being a bit stiff.

The bike has indeed been restored, but not by the PO, most likely by his predecessor. I feel the important factor is that it's been ridden very little since restoration a few years ago. It's my intention to correct that by putting plenty of miles on the clock!

I like your suggestion that there may be some bedding in needed. I'll change the oil as suggested above and ride it. Then we'll see how much of a problem there really is with the gearbox.

Nigel

limeyrob

I've had gearboxes with the correct oil level get surface corrosion inside from condensation if they have stood still a long time. The oil film drains off because its not getting renewed by use.  If that has happened is should all wear smooth with use.

NClark

Quote from: limeyrob on 26 Oct, 2026, 18:43 I've had gearboxes with the correct oil level get surface corrosion inside from condensation if they have stood still a long time. The oil film drains off because its not getting renewed by use.  If that has happened is should all wear smooth with use.

Thank you Rob, so regular riding may well be the answer. Fingers crossed 🤞

Nigel

Kev D

Nigel.
Re reading this thread brought back a dim memory  one of my B40s developingc gear box trouble.
    I do think it might've  been a problem changing down too but can't  recall exact details.
     I remember the solution though.
    The selectors turned out to be lumpy pattern parts that bore little resemblance  to the originals and  had given-up living up to their name.
    The late Pete Boniface who was our local BSA guru gave me box full of genuine selector forks.
   It wasn't a hard fix.