Gear Selection Problem

Started by NClark, 25 Oct, 2026, 13:53

Previous topic - Next topic

NClark

Quote from: Kev D on 27 Oct, 2026, 07:48 Nigel.
Re reading this thread brought back a dim memory  one of my B40s developingc gear box trouble.
    I do think it might've  been a problem changing down too but can't  recall exact details.
     I remember the solution though.
    The selectors turned out to be lumpy pattern parts that bore little resemblance  to the originals and  had given-up living up to their name.
    The late Pete Boniface who was our local BSA guru gave me box full of genuine selector forks.
   It wasn't a hard fix.
     

Thank you Kev.

I'm hoping not to have to go too deep into the gearbox innards. However if the easy options like changing the oil don't work, it's good to know that about pattern selector parts.

Nigel

NClark

It's time I gave an update on my B40 gear selection problems. I've changed the gearbox oil, refilling with SAE40 as advised. The old oil was clean, but smelled like EP gear oil.
Since then I've ridden the bike a few times. The problem changing down from third to second is still apparent when cold, though once warmed up for 3-4 miles the gearchange functions normally.
Before I bought it, the bike had been beautifully restored but ridden very little. For the future, I'm going to keep using the bike and hope the gearbox beds in. If it doesn't improve after a few hundred miles, I'll have to consider a spot of gearbox surgery.
Thanks all for your advice, it's much appreciated.

Nigel

rhyatt

Glad a bit improved, was the clutch pushrod maladjusted ?

NClark

I've been through the clutch adjustment, cable and pushrod. All seems okay to me.

Nigel

briancairns

Quote from: NClark on 25 Oct, 2026, 13:53 While I'm generally very pleased with my recently acquired 1961 B40, I've found an intermittent problem with gear selection. Starting off in first and going up through the gears is fine, but sometimes when coming down through the ratios, first and second will not engage.

When this happens the gear lever is almost locked solid, with very little movement. Changing up and down between third and fourth is unaffected, perfectly normal, but second and first are unavailable. This problem seems worse when engine and 'box are cold.

Stopping (without turning off the engine) often allows the lower gears to be selected after a few prods of the gear lever. Once warmed up, the lower gears will select on the move, though the slower the speed, the easier the third down to second change becomes. Once down into second, changing down to first isn't a problem.

Please can I ask if anyone has experienced similar symptoms, or what the cause could be? I'm wondering if there's an issue with the detent plungers engagement with the cam plate?? But I'm hoping not to need to dive that deep into the gearbox!

Nigel


I have a B31, so not sure your gearbox is similar or not . I had the same issue and resolved by adjusting control rod;
Lengthening the control rod will move the selector forks towards first and third gears
thus improving their engagement, shortening the rod moves the forks towards second
and forth. As you can see improving selection in one gear may affect the others
however it is worth trying the control rod first just take note of where you started.



NClark

Thank you Brian. I'm not sure the B40 has a comparable control rod, though I'm not entirely sure what the control rod is on a B31 gearbox.

Nigel

briancairns

Quote from: NClark on 05 Nov, 2026, 14:38 Thank you Brian. I'm not sure the B40 has a comparable control rod, though I'm not entirely sure what the control rod is on a B31 gearbox.

Nigel
The control rod adjusts the gear selector;

limeyrob

Nice pic but that's only on the rigid and plunger B group. A group and SA B group use a rotating selector and all the unit A,B,C use a selector plate (but the not the same one).  You can see how BSA simplified over the years.

briancairns

Quote from: limeyrob on 05 Nov, 2026, 15:44 Nice pic but that's only on the rigid and plunger B group. A group and SA B group use a rotating selector and all the unit A,B,C use a selector plate (but the not the same one).  You can see how BSA simplified over the years.
I wasn't sure...thanks for the info,,cheers

NClark

Thank for the info, everyday's a school day!

Unfortunately, with no such rod and adjustment on the B40 'box, work on the selectors means getting the gear cluster out. Before going that far, I'm going to ride a few miles, to see if the gear change action beds in and improves. Following extensive restoration by a previous owner, the bike has covered very few miles, so there's reason to hope the gearbox may get better.

Nigel

briancairns

Quote from: NClark on 05 Nov, 2026, 18:20 Thank for the info, everyday's a school day!

Unfortunately, with no such rod and adjustment on the B40 'box, work on the selectors means getting the gear cluster out. Before going that far, I'm going to ride a few miles, to see if the gear change action beds in and improves. Following extensive restoration by a previous owner, the bike has covered very few miles, so there's reason to hope the gearbox may get better.

Nigel

Hope all goes well