BSA Owners' Club Workshop Discussions

The BSA Workshop => Singles => Topic started by: Keith L on 23 Jul, 2020, 16:57

Title: 1946 BSA B31 Valve Springs
Post by: Keith L on 23 Jul, 2020, 16:57
I have just fitted new valve springs and the Exhaust Valve spring is under more compression than the inlet valve spring by around 4-5mm. Does anyone know if this is normal please. Keith L
Title: Re: 1946 BSA B31 Valve Springs
Post by: idie on 23 Jul, 2020, 18:57
Have you a spring seat fitted under one side only?
Title: Re: 1946 BSA B31 Valve Springs
Post by: Keith L on 23 Jul, 2020, 20:18
No, they are both sitting on seats. Keith L
Title: Re: 1946 BSA B31 Valve Springs
Post by: idie on 23 Jul, 2020, 20:55
I can only think that one valve is longer then the other. To be honest if it were me I wouldn't worry about it so long as the spring doesn't bind when the valve is fully open.
Title: Re: 1946 BSA B31 Valve Springs
Post by: DAVE BRADY on 24 Jul, 2020, 07:07
Good morning,

Are the valves the same length or is it the groove for the collets?  Is one too long or the other too short? 

Dave.
Title: Re: 1946 BSA B31 Valve Springs
Post by: Keith L on 24 Jul, 2020, 09:25
Thanks Idie and Dave. Food for thought. I have checked the parts list and found that the split collars for the inlet and exhaust are different part numbers. It is not possible to see the difference from the parts book illustration. Mine looked the same and I did keep them separated when I dismantled the valves. However the old springs were well mashed so I don't know if they were assembled wrongly. Keith
Title: Re: 1946 BSA B31 Valve Springs
Post by: Pete C on 24 Jul, 2020, 12:53
The valve stems are of different diameters, hence the difference in the colletts to fit the stems snugly. Try not to mix them up.

If you look very closely you will see that one set is slightly thicker than the other, these are for the inlet.
Title: Re: 1946 BSA B31 Valve Springs
Post by: Pete C on 24 Jul, 2020, 12:58
That still doesn't answer the spring compression issue tho.

If the spring sets are the same length then make sure they are sitting correctly inside the seats and that you do have matched collars and the collets are going into them fully.

Once fitted I usually whack the end of the valve stem with a "solid" hammer/drift to ensure everything is well seated and not about to fly apart when the engine starts up.
Title: Re: 1946 BSA B31 Valve Springs
Post by: Keith L on 24 Jul, 2020, 17:29
Thanks Pete C. Problem solved. Would you believe, I had one thick and one thin split collar on each valve! Once I put the thick ones on the inlet valve and the thin ones on the exhaust everything fell into place. Cheers. Keith L