BSA Owners' Club Workshop Discussions

The BSA Workshop => Twins => Topic started by: AndrewDS on 31 Oct, 2026, 11:25

Title: 71 A65T - drive side roller bearing to ball?
Post by: AndrewDS on 31 Oct, 2026, 11:25
Hi all

This may or may not be a complex question - I'll let you decide ;)

I'm currently rebuilding a 71 A65T.  The engine was running before strip down and seemed to be pretty strong with no obvious noises, although it would lose oil pressure when warm, hence the strip down.  Anyway, the crank is out and there is considerable damage to the timing side bush (which will need replacing) and also the timing side journal, which is going to need re-grinding to at least a couple of undersizes to get it smooth again.  There is also damage to the crankshaft timing side thrust face and thrust washer, where it looks like the two surfaces have both had a fair bit of contact.

But while all this is repairable, I'm wondering about the possibility of replacing the drive side roller bearing with a ball bearing.  Am I right in thinking this is an option?  And if so, what else would need to be considered if I did that?

Not considering any other timing side mods like end fed crank or roller bearing conversion at this time.

Sorry for the long question..





Title: Re: 71 A65T - drive side roller bearing to ball?
Post by: DAVE BRADY on 31 Oct, 2026, 12:11
Hi,

Some early A65s had ball a bearing but obviously BSA saw the roller as an improvement even though it would have been more expensive.  It sounds like your engine has had a tough time. Perhaps poor quality oil or oil not changed often enough and maybe a lot of end float.
As you will need to get quite a bit of remedial work done why not consider the end feed conversion now rather than later.
The combined needle roller/thrust bearing does not cost much more than good quality bush and the machining will probably cost the same. The work for the quill in the crank and the mods. to the cases will add to the cost. Ask SRM to give you a quote for both options - standard or end fed.
I have an A65 and my wife has an A10 both of which cover extensive mileages for nearly 30 years and only recently had any work done on the bottom ends due to the end feed conversions and running full detergent 20/50 with a proper filter.
If you intend to do any mileage or keep the bike for any length of time go for the end feed conversion with the specified roller main bearing.

Dave
Title: Re: 71 A65T - drive side roller bearing to ball?
Post by: AndrewDS on 31 Oct, 2026, 15:28
Thanks Dave - I'm not sure I can justify the amount of work involved in the end feed option.  Not so much the cost, but this is a bike which will probably only do about 1k miles or so per year, maybe ridden once or twice a week for leisure, at best.

Having seen the state of the crank on the TS though, I'd be keen on a rebuild option which eliminated (as much as possible) the end float, and if reverting to a ball bearing on the DS is an option, I'm keen to explore it. What I'm not sure of is how to centre the crank in order to calculate shims, that kind of stuff.

I know the ball bearing probably has a shorter life than a roller, and even though I'm not averse to changing it periodically, I'm assuming it will still last a few good years with the kind of usage I'd be giving it.
Title: Re: 71 A65T - drive side roller bearing to ball?
Post by: limeyrob on 03 Nov, 2026, 16:18
I would keep the drive side roller and get the crank ground and a new T/S bush.  All straight forward and proven to work.
I did a lot of miles on a tuned A65 with the std bottom end and its strong enough, the big weakness is the sludge trap and so I would always advise a cartridge oil filter on the return and regular oil changes.  I fitted a cartridge filter to my OIF A65, there was just space behind the engine, I wish I could remember exactly where!
End feed, needle/ball is a good mod but the standard bottom end with a filter should do 30k miles at least.
I recently rebuilt the bottom end on my A10RR. I got the machine shop to grind the crank until the surface was good, not to a dimension, then line ream to bush to fit and left the clearance up to them.  This will eke out at least one more grind before it goes undersize. (and fitted a filter) This means getting the solid bush not the steel / shell composite.
Title: Re: 71 A65T - drive side roller bearing to ball?
Post by: AndrewDS on 04 Nov, 2026, 16:05
Thanks Rob - I'm leaning back towards leaving it as standard, with the roller on the drive side and a custom bush sized to whatever size the timing side journal ends up after clean up.
Title: Re: 71 A65T - drive side roller bearing to ball?
Post by: DMadigan on 18 Nov, 2026, 17:18
Changing to a ball you need to check the crank journals are centered to the cylinder bores. Although the main bearings are the same size, the roller is located by the lip on the outer race and the thrust washer. The ball bearing locks the crank in place but still needs the thrust washer to keep the crank from pulling the bearing out of the case. The thrust washer is different between the two arrangements. The crank still needs to be shimmed for end float with the ball bearing.
The timing bush lasts a lot longer if you use a return filter. The crank centrifugal filter only filters after the oil has gone through the main bush.
A marine crank shop is a good place to look for the crank work. Usually they can hard face the crank and bring it back to standard. In the US, Marine Crankshaft in CA does good work.
If the thrust washer locating flange is torn up you could use an outrigger bearing in the primary with the roller bearing and eliminate the thrust washer.
Title: Re: 71 A65T - drive side roller bearing to ball?
Post by: AndrewDS on 18 Nov, 2026, 22:43
Quote from: DMadigan on 18 Nov, 2026, 17:18 If the thrust washer locating flange is torn up you could use an outrigger bearing in the primary with the roller bearing and eliminate the thrust washer.

The locating flange is good, as although the thrust washer and thrust face seem to have had contact, it (fortunately) didn't spin.  The thrust face is scored though and will need cleaning up - which I'm guessing will need to be taken into account when shimming for end float.

The crank and cases have been taken for machining and the plan is to remain standard, so roller drive side and plain bush on the timing side, once the timing side journal has been cleaned up.