BSA Owners' Club Workshop Discussions

The BSA Workshop => Singles => Topic started by: Janacek on 30 Oct, 2026, 17:06

Title: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: Janacek on 30 Oct, 2026, 17:06
My B31 has developed an odd noise.It's best described as midway between a whine and a moan from the right side.
It only seems to happen at low revs when pulling away,and disappears as speed increases.
Just changed the oil to Halfords Classic 20/50,but don't think that could cause this
I'm thinking a dry main bearing or dry camwheel bearing.
Any suggestions?
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: V500 on 30 Oct, 2026, 17:15
Try oiling the dynamo end bearing. A squirt of oil through the little hole on the end is usually plenty for the bush.
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: NClark on 30 Oct, 2026, 19:05
Quote from: V500 on 30 Oct, 2026, 17:15 Try oiling the dynamo end bearing. A squirt of oil through the little hole on the end is usually plenty for the bush.

I'm thinking the same. I've heard this kind of noise from a worn dynamo on a classic car.

Nigel
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: idie on 30 Oct, 2026, 20:56
Primary chain to tight?
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: Derek996 on 31 Oct, 2026, 10:38
Or insufficient clearance between the magneto pinion and the idler pinion although I don't see how this would change once set up and the magdyno clamping strap remains tight.
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: DAVE BRADY on 31 Oct, 2026, 11:11
Hi,

Doesn't the magdyno have a fibre pinion and a pressure plate/clutch to protect the fibre wheel? If this pressure is insufficient it can slip and make such a noise.  A bit like slack fan belt on a car.

Dave.
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: Derek996 on 31 Oct, 2026, 12:07
Yes it does. I've no idea what it would sound like but it's quite possible.
This is the setup for the fibre plate pressure.
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: V500 on 31 Oct, 2026, 17:31
Quote from: DAVE BRADY on 31 Oct, 2026, 11:11 Hi,

Doesn't the magdyno have a fibre pinion and a pressure plate/clutch to protect the fibre wheel?

As it's covered in grease and the spider bears on the fibre gearwheel it would have to slip an awful lot to be heard above the sound of the engine when pulling away.
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: DAVE BRADY on 31 Oct, 2026, 18:22
Hi,

It is possible so perhaps worth checking.

Dave.
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: DAVE BRADY on 31 Oct, 2026, 18:32
Hi,

Just found this.  It looks like the fibre pinion is held between two plates with the star washer against the outer one.
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: Janacek on 01 Nov, 2026, 16:58
Took the dynamo off and found it rather stiff to turn with finger and thumb.Too stiff to feel the magnetic pulses (unlike the magneto) so I'm guessing it needs new bearings.checking the internet,they are available.
It looks a straightforward job looking at my Haynes manual,providing it comes apart easily,but I am in two minds weather to tackle it myself,or send it to a specialist.
Has anyone replaced the dynamo bearings? Was it as straightforward as Haynes would have you believe?
Any comments or hints gratefully received.
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: cdsdorset on 01 Nov, 2026, 20:08
It is pretty straightforward.
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: V500 on 01 Nov, 2026, 22:07
The dynamo doesn't give the "magnetic pulses" effect as it has no points.
Dynamo's are simple enough, and you might find that a good clean and lube of the bearings (one ball race and one phos bush) and it's OK.
Both bearings have an easy time, so replacement (provided they've been occasionally lubed) is unusual.
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: Derek996 on 02 Nov, 2026, 11:12
The dynamo should be easy to turn my hand with very little resistance, and yes there are no pulses. As V500 says a good clean and lube of the bearings might be all it needs. If your dynamo is the short E3HM 45W one it will have a phosphor bronze bush at the commutator end. If it is the longer E3LM 60W one it will have a ball race at both ends. They are easy to change although the drive side one needs a bit of dismantling of the end plate.
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: limeyrob on 03 Nov, 2026, 14:00
Dynamo rebuild (so long as the windings are OK) is a simple DIY job.  They get dried grease on the armature that fouls on the magnet.
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: Dan_B33 on 08 Nov, 2026, 14:35
You will do it easily.
There is full How to video on YT.
I have used it to recondition mine.

Good luck

Dan
Title: Re: B31 unusual noise.
Post by: neil1964 on 11 Nov, 2026, 22:37
Hi Dan
I sent you a private message
Kind regards
Neil